Progressive overload: how and when to increase weight at the gym
The GymVox team ·
Progressive overload comes down to knowing when to increase weight: do it when you beat the reps your plan calls for by 1-2 in a given exercise, two workouts in a row. Then add 2-10%: less in small exercises such as biceps curls, more in big ones such as squats or deadlifts. Adding reps at the same weight is progression too, and in research it built muscle about as well.
Where does this rule come from, how do you use it in practice and what should you do when the weight has not moved for a month? Let's go step by step.
What is progressive overload
Your muscles adapt to the work you ask of them. If you do the same 3 sets of 10 reps with the same weight for six months, your body has no reason to keep changing. Progressive overload means gradually raising the demand: more weight, more reps or more sets.
The 2009 position stand of the American College of Sports Medicine (ACSM) lists progressive overload, along with specificity and variation, as one of the most important principles of long-term progress in strength training.
Three ways to progress
You can raise the demand in three main ways:
- Weight. Same number of reps, more weight. The simplest and best-known method.
- Reps. Same weight, more reps per set.
- Sets. More working sets per muscle group per week. How many that should be is covered in our guide how many sets per muscle group per week.
Does adding reps work as well as adding weight? Plotkin and colleagues tested this in 2022 on 43 people who already trained. For 8 weeks, one group increased the weight at a fixed number of reps, and the other increased the reps at a fixed weight. Muscle grew similarly in both groups. Strength rose slightly more in the group that added weight, but the authors judged the difference to be of little practical importance.
The takeaway: you do not have to add kilograms every workout. What matters is that something goes up, and you can alternate between increasing weight and reps.
The rule: when to increase weight
In its 2009 position stand, ACSM gives a simple rule. When you do 1-2 more reps than your plan calls for in a given exercise on two consecutive workouts, increase the weight by 2-10%. Use the smaller percentage for exercises that work small muscle groups and the larger one for exercises that work large muscle groups.
Requiring two workouts in a row, not one, keeps you from adding weight after a single unusually good day. Example: your plan calls for 3 sets of 8 reps on the bench press with 60 kg (132 lb). On two consecutive workouts you do 10 reps in the first set and at least 9 in the others. At your next workout, use 62.5 kg (138 lb).
How much to add: table
| Exercise | Example weight | How much to add | Percentage |
|---|---|---|---|
| Squat, deadlift | 80 kg (176 lb) | 2.5-5 kg (5-11 lb) | 3-6% |
| Barbell press, row | 60 kg (132 lb) | 2.5 kg (5 lb) | 4% |
| Dumbbell overhead press | 2 x 14 kg (2 x 31 lb) | 1-2 kg (2-4 lb) per hand | 7-14% |
| Biceps curl, lateral raise | 2 x 8 kg (2 x 18 lb) | 1-2 kg (2-4 lb) per hand | 12-25% |
The "How much to add" column shows an example rounded to the plates and dumbbells available in a typical gym. It also shows the problem with light dumbbells: the smallest available jump is often much bigger than 10% of the weight. In that case it is better to first add a few reps to every set, and only increase the weight once you clearly exceed the planned reps in every set.
Double progression: the simplest scheme
Double progression combines two methods from the previous section: first you add reps, then weight. It works like this:
- Pick a rep range, for example 8-12.
- Start with a weight you can do 8 reps with in every set.
- Over the next workouts, add reps: 8, 9, 10, until you reach 12 in all sets.
- Then increase the weight and start again from 8.
It is the same mechanism as the ACSM rule, just written out step by step. It works especially well for isolation exercises and dumbbell exercises, where the jump in weight is large.
How close to failure to take your sets
Progression only works when your sets are truly hard. If you finish a set with 6 more reps still in the tank, adding reps or kilograms will tell you nothing about your progress.
The RIR scale helps here (RIR stands for repetitions in reserve). Zourdos and colleagues described it in 2016: after a set, you rate how many reps you had left. RIR 0 means you could not do a single more rep, RIR 2 means you could have done two more. The authors considered it a practical way to adjust load from day to day, and in experienced lifters the ratings were strongly linked to bar speed: the higher the effort rating, the slower the bar moved.
In practice, finish most sets at RIR 1-3. If at a planned 8 reps you feel you could do 4 or more additional reps, the weight is too light and you can increase it sooner than the two-workout rule says.
When progress stalls
At first, weights go up almost every workout. Over time progress slows down, and that is normal. If you have not improved the weight or the reps in a given exercise for 3-4 weeks, check these in order:
- Sleep, food and stress. Without them, progress is hard no matter the plan.
- Technique. Sometimes the weight goes up only because your range of motion gets shorter. Go back to the full range of motion, even if it costs you a few kilograms.
- Number of sets. Too few sets may not give enough stimulus, too many may not let you recover.
- Changing the rep range. Switch from 6-8 to 10-12 reps for a few weeks, or swap the exercise for a similar one.
A commonly suggested fix is a deload, that is, a week of lighter training. Bell and colleagues in 2023 gathered the views of experienced strength and physique coaches. They agreed that a deload is a period of reduced training load meant to reduce physical and mental fatigue and prepare you for further work, and that after it you can raise the demand in the next cycle.
There is little research on deloading itself, though. Coleman and colleagues in 2024 compared 39 people training for 9 weeks: half took a week of complete rest in the middle of the program, the other half trained without a break. Leg muscles grew similarly in both groups, but strength increased more in the group without the break. So use a deload when fatigue is really building up, not every few weeks out of habit. A lighter week is also different from a week without training.
When not to add weight
Do not increase the weight when your technique clearly breaks down or the exercise causes joint or tendon pain. If pain keeps coming back with a specific movement, see a physiotherapist instead of waiting it out with a lighter weight. If you have a chronic condition, are pregnant, or are returning to training after an injury or surgery, agree on the pace of progression with your doctor first.
Frequently asked questions
How often should I increase the weight?
Not by the calendar, but by your results. Add weight when you do 1-2 more reps than your plan calls for in a given exercise on two workouts in a row. For beginners this happens often, for advanced lifters much less often.
How many kilograms should I add?
2-10% of your current weight: less in small exercises, more in big ones. In practice that is usually 2.5-5 kg (5-11 lb) on the squat and deadlift and 2.5 kg (5 lb) on presses and rows.
Do I have to add weight every workout?
No. Adding reps at the same weight is progression too, and in the study by Plotkin and colleagues it built muscle about as well as adding weight.
What is double progression?
A scheme in which you first add reps within a range, for example 8-12, and once you reach the top of the range in all sets, you increase the weight and go back to the bottom of the range.
What should I do when the weight stalls?
Check your sleep, food, technique and number of sets. Changing the rep range, swapping the exercise for a similar one, or a lighter week when you feel very tired can also help.
Should women progress the same way?
The rule is the same: add weight when you clearly beat the plan. With lighter weights, a 2.5 kg (5 lb) jump can be a large percentage, so smaller plates or progressing by reps are more often useful.
Remember what you did last time
To know when to add weight, you need to remember how many reps you did and with what weight on your last two workouts. GymVox, our AI personal trainer you talk to by voice, guides you through your workout set by set and logs every set, so your result from the previous workout is always at hand. You can start for free on iPhone and Android.
Sources:
- American College of Sports Medicine (2009). Progression Models in Resistance Training for Healthy Adults. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 41(3), 687-708.
- Plotkin D., Coleman M., Van Every D. et al. (2022). Progressive overload without progressing load? The effects of load or repetition progression on muscular adaptations. PeerJ, 10, e14142.
- Zourdos M.C. et al. (2016). Novel Resistance Training-Specific Rating of Perceived Exertion Scale Measuring Repetitions in Reserve. Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, 30(1), 267-275.
- Bell L., Strafford B.W., Coleman M., Androulakis Korakakis P., Nolan D. (2023). Integrating Deloading into Strength and Physique Sports Training Programmes: An International Delphi Consensus Approach. Sports Medicine - Open, 9, 87.
- Coleman M. et al. (2024). Gaining more from doing less? The effects of a one-week deload period during supervised resistance training on muscular adaptations. PeerJ, 12, e16777.
This article is for information only and does not replace advice from a coach, doctor or physiotherapist.